512
Hi, the anon from previously, the reason I mentioned being a teen is because I studied developmental psychology and teenage years are when you form your identity so you naturally project a lot. I think it's a good way of handling that time of your life and so I want people to be understanding of teens who are trying to find themselves
Oh yeah, absolutely, and I completely agree. The reason we give teenagers leeway - the reason we HAVE to give teenagers leeway - is exactly because they are developing so much and so quickly that they have no idea who they'll be in 6 months time. Finding a character or a series or something that resonates with you is such an excellent grounding point for that, and although my wife and I do very frequently go "what are you 15" when we're getting annoyed at people on the internet, it's always with the knowledge that teenagers are always going to have their fair share of Mishaps.
public service announcement to any teenagers reading this: you're allowed to be a little bit annoying sometimes. It's not a crime. You're still a kid, live a little.
Anyway yeah no I agree thank you for your points! Have a great day
No hate to people responding to your post, but I think it's very telling when people who do mention projecting/relating. Mizuki is not any of these people, she's a fictional character in a fictional story, written in a specific way, if you want to engage in analysis, you have to remember that. But if you don't want to have conversations/analyze, projecting onto characters is a normal part of growing up and being a teen that you'll grow out of anyways so it's fine to acknowledge the character you like isn't actually the character in the story
It's a little frustrating to me how unwilling people are to accept that they're projecting and to be able to analyse the media and the characters outside the lens of their projection. We all project onto characters all the time in so many different and often indeterminable ways but we need to learn how to cut away as many of our unconscious biases as possible to actually Read The Story. and yet people are so afraid to do so. It's rather unfortunate.
I do somewhat reject your pithy phrasing of 'being a teen', though I assume that was at least mostly a joke and the rest of it is genuine. Teenagers do project a ton, absolutely, and you're correct to say that people grow out of it some, but we all project at least a little bit sometimes. And that's okay! We just need to know that. For example, I know my instinctive hc for most of the characters in this game is that they're bisexual. That is in large part because I am bisexual, and so I do not place too much stock in that headcanon unless I have stronger and relevant evidence for it. I acknowledge my bias and disregard it when speaking to people about canon material where appropriate.
Hiii, not oomfs or anyth anon again :>
I still think her love for femininity and passing as any other woman, still wouldnt put her in a box for just a woman, and ntg but, bcs if it does, itd make me sad, cus i see myself in her, i will admit this is on a personal thing, all ill say is, boxes are a bit saddening in my eyes, secure, but saddening, even in a case of canonicity where feelings are irrelevant
and i do understand "i dont exist in a vacuum", but u dont either, this space for mizuki isnt for just transgirls alone in my eyes, and thts a good thing. Im not saying she cant be a girl, im saying she can be not a girl too
Her canon state is still mizuki, a girl OR very fem nb bcs of her gender marker in game, femininity or passing as a woman can still mean more for her too.
I will admit i worry this does come off as misogynistic a bit, but i feel like being a bit loud abt my stance on mizukis gender this time, bcs her writing is a space for all fems to me, and calling her a fem, instead of just a girl is only bad and a ticking time bomb bcs of ppl who suck,
and i dnt think i wnna give them the time of day or space or attention to ride off a queer persons views to perpetuate misogynistic stuff, when the qp didnt share those views at all, why are we tlking like the qp is to blame? Bcs other ppl suck? Thats not fair to the qp, bcs our space is ours
I do think however ill be not here on ur page anymore, ur post found me at a bad time for me, so i do hope this dsnt come off as rude or angry again, but goodbyee ^^
Hey there. I appreciate you coming back, and I'm sorry that I seem to have upset you a little. I promise that wasn't my intention.
To be frank, though, I think you're taking this a little more personally than you should. I should reiterate again that I am not holding any individual person responsible for anything, and I want to make efforts against a trend of behavior, not individual actions.
There is no reason that Mizuki has to be a perfect 1:1 of your experiences for you to see yourself in her. She is, wholeheartedly, for all transfems. Just because she herself is a trans woman does not mean her story and narrative and character are somehow hidden away and stolen from you. Every single transfem that has existed and will ever exist could recognize some of themselves in her, and that's wonderful.
I just think that you don't need to recycle and ignore aspects of Mizuki to make the true perfect transfem nb representation you deserve.
Ultimately, again, your life is yours to live. I do not care, really, if you look at all this and decide that you don't care, and you're still going to call Mizuki transfem nb. That isn't a problem to me, and you don't need to justify it to me. All I ask is that you do your best to be kind, and to understand where I'm coming from. Even if you disagree or even if you agree, but don't want to change.
hi oomf of an oomf here i just wanted to say i am sooo glad that i happened to open twt today and come across your writing T_T heard many good things about you but i dont use the site much anymore so hadnt had the chance to meet yet..... anyway AAAH thank you so much!! for writing so candidly about mizukis transness and about transmisogyny and about femininity and about the construct of gender etc (and for being so right about those things, haha). for example in that response to a strawpage anon, i was really pleasantly surprised when u were willing to come out and directly say “I think fem nb hcs actually can harm people”; thats an opinion i share and sort of understand intrinsically/experientially but have had a lot of trouble articulating in the past and would b too afraid to state openly now, and you explained it really well in the alterspring post… it meant a lot to me and inspired me, i guess, as someone who gave in to equivocation when trying to talk about these things in this space, seeing you speak so specifically and uncompromisingly (that ofc goes for other posts too). idk!!! im rlly sorry if im coming on too strong or anything theres one small point id be interested in discussing further but i dont want to be too presumptuous lol. Mostly just wanted u 2 know u made me feel seen & that i see u too and i respect u. take care
Oh thank you so much!!! I'm genuinely so so glad that I could inspire even a little bit of confidence in somebody else. All I want is to improve things, and it's wonderful to hear I've succeeded in any small way.
Very weird to see that apparently people talk about me lmao but that's weird in a good way. Feel free to hit me up at any time! My DMs are open to all. Even if you hated me you would be free and welcome to DM me lmao. No promises I'll get back to you immediately or anything, obviously, but I would love to chat.
Again, thank you so much! I hope you have a wonderful day.
https://x.com/happynarrator/status/2109614307449487765
Hey, im the "not oomfs or anything" anon,
I understand that, but you cant keep talking about fem nb hcs as this part of bigger issue so easily, bcs as a fem nb myself, i want rep too. This isnt just a case where "we shldnt be fighting each other for rep", its also that we, as fem nbs, are fully allowed to see her as rep of us BCS she has ambiguity to her gender, even post-mizuena5, ESPECIALLY post-mizuena5, without being read as transmisogynistic. we are in the same boat, for the same character, and we love her, so so dearly.
So dont dismiss fem nb hcs of mizuki too easily with how u say it, thats all. Bcs its not fair to imply that us wanting rep as much as ANY QUEER does as this budding seed for tmisogyny. Its how ACTUAL misogynistic ppl choose to react to our want of this that wld cause more tmiso. Not us. Thats all..
/lh /nm
Srry i rlly am not super mad, and i do hope it dsnt come off that way, u just rlly irked me a bit haha.. i hope u understand ú_ù'" /gen
Look, girl, I don't know how to tell you this, and I really hope you understand I don't mean this with any hate or malice in my heart:
I can, and I will. There's a couple different avenues I want to explore this down, so please walk with me here.
Imagine, for a moment, that you see a person on the street. They are wearing a pink frilly dress, have their face done in full makeup, long hair, and have a high pitch to their voice. How do you refer to them, even in your head? Do you assume that she's a woman, or do you go "oh, I don't know them, so they could be anything?"
The 'woke' answer is "oh, I don't know them", but that isn't how you respond in reality. Nobody actually does. Everybody just makes assumptions, because we're human. You assume she's a woman, and treat her as such. You do this with every single woman you pass on the street. If you say otherwise, you are lying to me.
Okay, cool. Now, let's step forward a little. She's talking to her friends, and her voice slips. Suddenly, you recognise that she's clearly been doing voice training. Or maybe you get a little closer and you realise that she's a little tall, or that she has an Adam's apple, or that she looks a little more 'masculine' than you would have expected, or you notice they're wearing a trans pin, or you realise that you've heard about them before, and you know that they're trans (but it's just a rumour, so you don't know the full details). Maybe even you knew them when they were younger, and you know that they certainly didn't dress like that before. Whatever it is, you know that they're trans. You can tell they are not a cis woman. No other aspect of their presentation has changed, at least not intentionally.
How do you respond? Do you assume that she's a woman, or do you say that you don't know their pronouns, so it could be anything?
Do you see the issue here?
This is the entire crux of Mizuki's character. She wants to pass. She does not just want to be known as trans, she wants to be treated the same as any other girl. Every aspect of how she expresses herself is feminine, and she's horrified at the thought that people will interpret it any other way. By clocking the random trans woman on the street, you are actively dismantling every sign she is giving you that she is a trans WOMAN, and you are refusing to see her as she presents herself.
This is what I mean when I say this behavior perpetuates transmisogyny. Why do you think Mizuki is fem nb? Is it just because you, personally, are fem nb, and want to see yourself in the girl you love? Because that is completely fine! There is absolutely nothing wrong with that, and, congratulations, you have passed my woke test, collect your $0 and go on your way. But... What is Mizuki in canon? What do you think Mizuki is, in canon? Why is she canonically fem nb, instead of a binary trans woman? Because I don't care what you, personally, think as a headcanon. You are free to headcanon anything you want. But you don't exist in a vacuum, and I'm not really speaking to you, personally.
Additionally, I wholly reject that Mizuki has any ambiguity to her gender post mizuena5. We know explicitly that she is amab, that she becomes suicidal at the mere thought of that fact being exposed, and that she does not want to be seen as anything other than who she is. We know she does not want to be treated ANY DIFFERENTLY than she was before, which was, to Niigo, as a cis woman. There is no other way that they would have assumed she identified, because it doesn't make SENSE. In canon, they assumed she was a cis woman. The fact that the EN localisation started using they/them is literally a plot hole. We do not exist in a world where people use they/them as cis people. The only ways that Mizuki would have been referred to are as he/him or she/her, and we know damn well it wasn't he/him. So all Mizuki wants is for everything to go back to what it was before, where Niigo refers to her as a woman, and thinks of her as a woman, and in all way presumes that she is just a 'normal' woman.
What part of that reads as nonbinary?
Again, I don't mean any of this as a personal attack on you, the reader, specifically. But being queer doesn't prevent you from ever committing a micro- or macro-aggression, it doesn't prevent you from being transmisogynistic, and it doesn't mean you shouldn't engage in self-reflection.
Thanks for reading. I hope you understand my point. I do not mind if you disagree with me on some of the technicals, but please try to understand the totality of my argument, rather than quibble over any of the little details.
sayanon!!
hello i have to discoursepost a little bit. top of the post: i think we're all being a little bit unrealistic when we say pjsk is "targeted at" young teenagers. i wouldn't say that's necessarily the case; i think young teenagers are PART OF the general expected audience, and so the story is designed as such that it's GENERALLY appropriate for them. realistically, i feel as though the game is targeted at mid-late teens and adults under ~30, a group that sounds really broad but actually primarily includes "people with low oversight on their spending habits and significant disposable income" eg. teenagers working summer jobs or young professionals (you could narrow this range, generally, to 16–25). basically EVERY gacha game is targeted at this range by nature of being a gacha game.
honestly, i just don't buy the idea that the average 12-year-old is meaningfully engaging with this game and its story and characters, and i'm saying this as someone who was once myself 12 and playing SIF before school every day. i only liked love live because there were several ways to consume the story and characters beyond "5000 hours of kind of boring gacha game storyline that you have to catch up on to really understand what's happening" (good lord if it was just the SIF story i would NOT have liked love live). 12-year-olds, broadly, just kind of dgaf about anything that isn't like, as exciting and fun and novel as a giant laser pointer being waved around for them to chase, and reading years and years of story backlog is not going to do it for most kids. i personally know someone who is 13 and plays this game without reading anything and i think just thinks "akito is hot" while trying to build the "Most Aesthetic" team she can. that doesn't mean every kid does this, but i'm more inclined to believe that most do.
i also want to note that i think pretty significant portions of the pjsk story are genuinely very hard for young teenagers to properly understand the emotional resonance of. i think light up the fire is a big one here (honestly, the vivid street adults in general are part of this) but i also think a lot of the nightcord story is like, genuinely more mature than we're giving it credit for. yes we talk around words like "suicide" all the time, but it's fair to say that the game often interfaces with the ideas that adults have their own complex interiorities that they sometimes take out inappropriately on kids, especially THEIR kids. mafuyu's mother is a big part of this here, but so too is shinei, so too are taiga and nagi, and i think one could make such an argument for harumichi as well. a game truly "targeted at kids" (similarly to young adult literature) is one that would engage much more heavily with the idea of "my dad is just evil actually"; i think this is important just because the story has worked SO HARD to portray the idea that shinei is a complex man with his own complex problems AND ena knows that she was tough to handle when she was younger and her father wasn't entirely wrong AND ena is still mad about it because he was being a dick as a result and that wasn't fair to her. that's a lot for the "Target audience" of Young Teens to try to process mentally, and i think the depth of it really can only be understood by someone old enough to have proper hindsight on their childhood.
ok but like the actual discourse: this isn't to say anything about the concept of "sexualizing" characters in this game; i think it's ok (and we all need to get a little more comfortable with the idea overall) that you can be Kind Of Weird and there's nothing wrong with being Kind Of Weird sometimes. more on this in a second but tbh it requires a broader discussion on Characters and Fiction first.
more importantly, i think we all tend to forget that everyone's understanding of any character is actually like... their own personal abstraction of that character as exists in Their Head, Individually. my version of mafuyu is different from your version of mafuyu is different from someone else's mafuyu is different from the canon mafuyu. as a result, my version of mafuyu is influenced by all sorts of things about me — my age, my personality, my interests, my priorities in life. that doesn't mean i think mafuyu is a grad student who likes love live, but it does mean that my mafuyu is influenced by being part of the imagination of a grad student who likes love live. that means that my version of mafuyu is influenced both by the things i thought and felt around her age but also the things i think and feel now. my mafuyu is (to an extent) both 18 and my age, because she is influenced (even in ways i probably can't identify directly!) by the fact that I Am My Current Age.
i say all of this because i think we've kind of conflated all discussion of sexuality with these characters as being "weird." but i do think that's a little silly? people can certainly be weird about it, but i think we're all acting like sex and sexuality aren't important parts of "coming of age" (and, in most cases, the general concept of a coming of age story); pjsk is unusually allergic to discussing it because they don't want even a hint of an implication that two characters might be Dating-Dating (or similar things; i think this is a result of a mixed-gender cast, which most games like this don't really have). but like... i think it's okay to think about how these characters might wrestle with these experiences. i know i certainly was thinking about this a lot around the ages these characters are.
okayyy but all of that said: top/bottom discussion is one of those things that's like, unfortunately very timeless. i think it is just a rite of passage that every single like, teenager with an opinion has to progress from "top and bottom are a personality thing haha this character is such a bottom haha" to "ohhh actually this is just a sex thing and it's really weird to insist someone's sexual preferences are personality traits." i think younger ppl especially tend to think of it as another arbitrary Personality Classification in the same way as like "red/blue ship" and "pink/purple yuri" and stuff like that.... and it's a long-standing tradition that eventually you mature enough to go "ohhh uhh hm no it's no the same at all." i'm sure 14-year-olds were having this same debate about like, sasuke/naruto in the early 2000s, and i'm sure other 14-year-olds were doing it before that too, much in the same way that people are doing it today about pjsk characters and genshin characters and anything else trendy among young people. as you said: this has been discussed extensively, some of you are just 21.
that was a lot of words for my opinion to be "idk man maybe it depends" and "some of you are being very 21 about this" and "some of you are being even MORE 14 about this" and, ultimately, i must conclude with: i might be too old for this discourse, but by god that will NOT stop me from saying "you guys are all so fucking 12 about this please stop it." thanks for reading !!
hello sayanon! thank you for the feast
The question of what demographic pjsk is targeted at is complicated, because I think the answer really ultimately relies on one very silly little question: what do you mean by 'project sekai?'
I think there are three (and a half) separate axes pjsk operates on. One is the Vocaloid Rhythm Game, which is 1.5 axes, comprised mostly of the Vocaloid Rhythm Game but also partially just as a Vocaloid Game, one is the Tiering Gacha Game, where you spend a million dollars and play for 100 hours straight to get a funny png, and then the final one is the Visual Novel, where you read a 12 million page book and get emotional about anime girls. Not all of these aspects have perfect overlap in terms of what their core audience are, and I think that the game understands that, and a great part of its success is by allowing these axes to develop their own cores.
I completely agree that a lot of young teens - though I struggle to call a 13 year old a teenager, despite them literally being one - do not quite have the emotional maturity, in many cases, to fully grasp some of the complexities of the pjsk story. That's not to go "oh pjsk is actually the deepest storytelling ever" but rather that. Well. My little sister is 13, and is exactly as bad as the kid you describe. she literally will not read the stories. something something all the kids have adhd these days or whatever the stereotype is. i have no idea if i was that bad at 13 and just didn't know it or if exposure to tiktok is a type 12 carcinogen for the brain specifically but whatever it is I don't think most 13 year olds and younger I know are Capable of reading pjsk without copious application of the Ludovico Technique.
The visual novel of pjsk feels much more intended at probably the 15+ range, imo? but I also think it's worth acknowledging that it might just be that they've written a story that's actually good, and by introducing 'nuance' and 'developed characterisation' they've just written all-age-accessible media of a tier that we should be expecting more often. But again, as I said on twitter - the strength of a chain is its weakest link. To be frank, while we can while away about whether the game is intended for 10 or 13 or 15 or 36 year olds, the lowest age bracket the game intends to service IS low, and the game does make efforts to appeal and conform to the standards desired and required by those demographics, and there are always going to be children in these fandom spaces.
... this is a lot of words and I'm just kind of waffling in circles, so I'm just going to say my point properly to make sure it's coming out right:
Since the developers know and want young people to play the game, the game has to comport to certain standards. Despite this, the story does have a lot of wonderfully complex characterisation and narrative compared to contemporary 'children's media'. I am unsure why they write the story well, whether it's because they trust children to understand it or whether the story is primarily intended for the older portions of their player base. Regardless of this, the game is most definitely intended for minors, as in people who are under 18, and when we are engaging with the game, we should be mindful of that.
and all of THAT is to get around to the actual discourse:
You are completely correct that we all need to get a lot more understanding of the fact that the way we interpret fiction is ultimately something that mirrors aspects of ourselves. The moment you realise "who I am as a person interferes with every single part of my ability to internalise the world around me" is the moment you get a lot more capable of dealing with people who disagree with you on the internet. Either you see yourself in a character, or you can't, and both of these things inform how you interpret that character.
I... am glad we are this far down in the alterspring, so that I can say this with minimal chance of getting dogpiled by people taking this out of context: I think there is absolutely nothing wrong with discussing the sexuality and sexual behaviors (IN A NORMAL WAY) of fictional minors. I think some fiction SHOULD explore these things, and I think it is not only natural but completely healthy to want to explore these aspects of life in any kind of fiction you enjoy and partake in. Project Sekai itself does not choose to engage in these things, which is completely fine and not an issue at all (barring the occasional realisation of "damn surely one of them would have mentioned a crush by now") but. like. if you as a person want to discuss or think about or write about the concept of Ichika Hoshino Having Sex, Usually With A Woman But God Forbid Maybe Even With A Man, then that is, actually, completely fine. That being an aspect of the way you engage with this piece of fiction is a completely value-neutral concept. You are allowed to do that. In canon, even if you discard shipping entirely, if you view these characters as Real People, then a ton of them WOULD be wrestling with these things! Regardless of what you think Akito's sexuality is, the scenarios he is placed in for canon would almost certainly prompt some internal reflection on his part about his sexuality and how he feels about Various Sexual Things. that's NORMAL. we all went through this in puberty! or soon after puberty! even if your answer was "i'm not interested" you still had to figure that out!
Now, obviously, there are caveats to this. There are a ton of caveats to all of this. Most people who engage in sexual discussion of media publicly tend to be... a little strange... about it, and people who do not want to engage in it usually really do NOT want to engage with it, and even people who would engage in it otherwise will often feel personally uncomfortable with doing it to teenage characters, or doing it too Much with teenage characters, and often people who engage with it actively tend to play around with things that are bordering on or literally just actually both illegal and immoral, or whatever the fuck else, but there's so many things to evaluate there that trying to evaluate them all is a fool's errand. My stance on it will always, always, ALWAYS be that I cannot stop you from thinking and feeling whatever you think and feel, but if you know that it will hurt people or make them uncomfortable, you should at least make sure it is abundantly clear what they'll be getting into if they check your page. Like-
oh my god hold on i've just realised how long this tangent has been. good lord i get distracted when i don't have a character limit. anyway sex is a normal part of the human experience and wanting to explore it in fiction is a value-neutral concept and the important part is what you do after that and how you do it and how many people you hurt in the process (more than 0 is bad!). i am just a random person on the internet it is not my place to determine whether you've committed a thoughtcrime.
Anyway, top/bottom discourse: This is SO timeless. People have been doing this since fucking, kirk/spock, I'm pretty sure, and for some reason, it still hasn't stopped. Ultimately, top/bottom discourse is one of three things in my mind:
1) An actual discussion about how the two characters have sex. This is not something I personally care about, but if you care about it, good for you!
2) teenagers not understanding that this is literally a sex thing, as you've said (i have nothing meaningful to add lmao), or
3) the bizarre fucking 'who wears the pants' and 'okay but which one of you is the man and which one is the woman' hetero-ification of every single romantic and sexual dynamic that has ever existed ever. That's what most of it amounts to, in my experience, and if I think about it too hard I get really mad about it. So much of top/bottom discourse revolves around the dynamic of 'the bottom is the submissive one' and thus, by extension, 'the submissive one is the woman', and it's REALLY uncomfortable. I have hated the seme-uke Discussions literally since the day I found out about them, and my opinion has not wavered since that fateful day at like 14 years old or something. The fact of the matter is that most top/bottom discourse, when distilled to its base elements, is assigning the more Assertive or Dominant or Masculine one of the two to be the Top, the Man of the pair, and the more Feminine and Soft and Submissive of the two to be the Woman. And that's really gross! That's like super gross! But unfortunately it is not something we can avoid, because this kind of intrinsic understanding of a relationship dynamic is not baked into fandom culture as much as it's baked into the superstructure of capitalism itself, and none of us will be free of it for at least a few more generations. it still is definitely a sex thing though. like the fact that it's a more unconscious "who's the man and who's the woman" does not negate the fact that it's just a sexual dynamic thing. it's just that the Man v Woman dichotomy is ALSO a sex thing, because blah blah blah patriarchy etc etc if you're woke enough you know what i'm talking about and if you're not you tuned out like three paragraphs ago. anyway we need to stop treating sex dynamics as important aspects of shipping it's really weird and says a lot about the people talking about it.
I just went up to scan through what I've written and. Yeah, maybe I shouldn't have made an alterspring, actually, I sure know how to Yap. Ultimately, yeah, a lot of it is really complicated, and the answers to most of it are either "it depends", "it doesn't matter", or "you guys are being really weird about this for no reason". thank you for your ask and thank you for reading.
obligatory disclaimer at the bottom, because I don't trust Project Sekai Twitter as far as I can throw it: Hi! I'm a real human person. If you have an issue with something I've said, please DM me, or send me an ask, or something. I am sure I have glossed over something, or said something in a way you find weird, or whatever. I am always happy to discuss things with people. Please do not attack me because you thought the implications of something I said had bad vibes. No I do not endorse/encourage/enjoy anything that hurts or could hurt real life people, especially children. okay thank you for reading bye. 1886 words btw
(sayanon)
okay everyone time to pack it up we've done enough "is emu stingy by not paying for her friends to fly to the US" discourse and we're starting to move from jokes to being uncomfortably serious about this. so now i must write my impassioned defense of emu's spending habits because we are SLANDERING my girl and i refuse to let this stand unchallenged
emu is definitely the "rich girl" archetype in some ways, but i think it's important to remember that she explicitly defies them in other ways. yes, emu's family is genuinely comically rich and well-connected, but emu is NOT mari ohara, not even a little bit?? money is still very "real" to her, even if she spends extravagantly. more on this in a minute though.
first of all, i think the characterization of Capitalist Emu is just like. wrong lmfao. one of emu's primary motivations is protecting the financial viability of PXL, and we know she is actually embarrassed/frustrated by her own naivete on this front. her primary motivation for the past couple years of real time has focused on her learning how to make her dreams realistic without needing to compromise — she wants to improve her knowledge about management and finances so she can figure out how to make her aspirations for PXL work (rather than figuring out how to make PXL as profitable as possible). the whole point of emu6 is that she wants EVERYONE to be able to succeed, but she knows that their current structure can't support both troupes financially, so she sits down and tries to figure out a realistic solution to allow both troupes to continue.
importantly, i wanted to highlight her own embarrassment here — emu IS embarrassed that she used to be totally ignorant about the finances of the park. obviously, this is understandable (she is literally like 17), but she desperately wants to be taken seriously as a member of her own family (rather than just being the baby) and she KNOWS that that means she's going to have to get a lot smarter about business & start being more self-sufficient.
now, on the other hand, we DO know that emu spends extravagantly sometimes... but in the examples i've seen floating around (eg Rainbow Canvas) the whole point is that she's spending "her" money? yes she spent an insane amount of money on a tube of paint, but she notes it as being "her allowance" — this is money that is HERS, not money she's taking from the business. also obviously the reason the paint is so expensive is as a rich-girl-trope joke but this is a bit in a mixed event and i wouldn't take it too seriously regardless.
taken together, we know that emu is someone who comes from a lot of wealth and as a result has a pretty high standard of living derived from the people around her. she's definitely a person who like learned at age 10 or something that there's a part of the plane behind first class, thought that "flying normally" meant flying commercial instead of private, like, that type of situation. however, we also know that emu places a TON of importance on being financially responsible with the otori group's money, since she knows that every bit counts when it comes to keeping PXL (as she wants it to be) alive. we also know that emu is willing to leverage the non-financial resources she has (eg. connections, items the group already has) elsewhere to get opportunities her her and her friends.
i also think it's worth remember that wxs as a whole all feel deeply indebted to the otori group for what they HAVE received from them for "business purposes" (and also that the things they've received have been almost?? exclusively for business reasons). they've gotten to travel all around japan AND to the US before for business, because they WERE working, even if they spent a lot of time goofing around in the stories. obviously, as well, they've gotten a special deal to be pxl-affiliated freelancers, and the otori group's connections to other troupes are what let wxs get many of their present opportunities. i find it really unlikely that they would want to ask emu's family for even more??? truly???
as for "why did emu not offer to pay in nene7" — she almost certainly used her own money to buy her ticket, unless i'm mistaken (also it's not like the tenmas aren't ALSO quite rich, even if it isn't anywhere near otori-level...). do you think the average 17-year-old, especially one trying to be more responsible and business-minded, is going to ask her family business to finance a trip for her and some of her friends to go see a broadway show???? same applies for the "the otori group has a private jet" arguments. elephant in the room as well: it's just kind of boring if we use the otori group to justify everything wxs ever does lol
anyway tldr: nene7 is bad for its own reasons we need to stop slandering emu for being a dirty capitalist or whatever. my girl is just young and wants to be more responsible so she can have an actual say in how pxl runs. rant over thank u for reading
hiya saya!
This is a really good read thank you for this one! A lot of this covers things I've genuinely not thought about before this and I really appreciate your insight here!
I've been trying not to read into the jokes too much, because I was pretty sure they were just jokes, but I have felt kind of weird about the tone of a lot of them because they've been getting a lot more mean over time and I couldn't tell how much of it was me reading too into it vs it being actually mean-spirited.
I really do like the fact that emu being the Rich Girl archetype is explicitly relevant and massively impactful to her character arc and development. The Rich Girl who takes Private Helicopters to school or whatever is just an anime trope and it can be very funny so the use of it in pjsk wasn't unexpected but the way they kind of subverted it has been really nice to see! I feel like Wanting To Be A Manager is a character arc that people generally have a harder time connecting to - which I think is a worthy discussion in and of itself, that people don't treat emu's character that seriously because her arc is pretty distant from a lot of us - but I do really like it, especially with the overtones of misogyny implicit to her character.
As such, yeah, no, I completely agree with your takeaways. Emu's personal spending isn't actually on the company credit card, and that is important! Treating the Otori Group as her personal financiers would be really irresponsible and also make the Hyper Rich Conglomerate lose a lot of narrative weight (that they can't really afford to lose, lmao) and I'm glad they're not just leaning into the trope. Emu is more than a rich girl! She's a person too! She is aware of her privilege!
Thank you for ranting! My mental concept of Emu is still a little shaky compared to a lot of the other characters so this isn't the kind of thing I'd be super comfortable starting a discussion of, and so I really appreciate you bringing it up. I really like her, but she's just so easy to flanderise.
she deserves better. i love that little pink thing
(sayanon!!)
was pleasantly surprised by how good the maintenance compensation was this time!! 700 crystals + 5 large cans is really pretty generous and was more than i expected even in the "holy shit maintenance 9/11" scenario. like tbh most ppl weren't harmed at all from this fuckup, but also it gave everyone quite the scare so i think this type of compensation was a really nice gesture from colopale. i think their biggest crime is that they probably should've approved someone tweeting/posting in the discord like "we are aware of a problem currently affecting paid crystals and are investigating the cause" like 30 minutes later instead of offering radio silence until the game went down again. i feel like a lot of the mass panic online arose just came from the lack of communication tbh.
that said, i feel awful for the kasa6 tierers LOL. short event made shorter by maintenance, then that maintenance got extended, THEN everyone's paid crystals were gone, AND THEN they had to go back into emergency maintenance. in my timezone, that was like the entire afternoon and evening so i didn't even get to do my dailies after work, and i just consider myself lucky that i'm not tiering this one. the paid crystals also uniquely fucked tierers over too, there were a couple hours in there where anyone in the upper LB had to choose between spending even MORE money and sacrificing tiering hours... i lowkey was wondering if they were going to extend the event after all of this, but no dice lol, i just won't be able to pick up the wish drops this time ig
i've seen a weird amount of doomposting from pjsktwt about this and im genuinely not sure why. in particular, i've seen a lot going on about "all of the problems" this year... and it's like, 6 short-lived kind-of-problems spread across four different teams? like the ppl responsible for the rui gacha nightmare are probably not the same people responsible for the en fuckup today. the rui gacha thing is like the only legit real "problem" all year, but i still feel like ppl blew it out of proportion a lot... it's literally pulling off-banner on bloomfes for very recent cards; realistically thats a very tiny number of ppl genuinely affected. in fact, the number was small enough that it took them several days to realize it happened in the first place LOL. it does suck for them, don't get me wrong, but it was like a legit mistake that only mattered to a small number of people, especially since the majority of players wouldn't have been pulling for those cards specifically and would have maybe picked up one or two of them incidentally.
i've also seen a lot of ppl talking about the VERY BRIEF window where ppl could get lims from ads on en, which is ALMOST CERTAINLY a different team entirely from the jp issues? idk i don't really know why people were mad about that one. you had your chance to get a lim from ads the same as anyone else, you just didn't roll it. to be clear: i did my ads that day and didn't roll the lim... bc i didn't roll a 4 star. getting a totally random lim from your ads with NO GUARANTEE that it will be useful or new to you or one you like at all....... idk man i just don't think that's a huge deal. it's kind of just the equivalent of doing a solo off recofes and going "oh shit a 4 star" and it turns out to be a lim. the biggest thing i would have done is left it running for the full 24 hours just to give all players an equal opportunity on it, but i also understand why they didn't. as for the most recent en issue i've already kind of said my piece on it, my main issue is that they did not post One Singular Tweet saying "we know about it uhhh we're working on it sorry" before the mass panic set in online.
anyway i'm obviously a global player but similarly i think the complaints about the tw/kr servers having that very short-lived issue with vbswl2 are like. also a bit overblown. i think they addressed it well. since it was a world link too like... if you were tiering for toya i think you would have probably been playing during that time anyway? such is the nature of tiering a wl chapter??? and if you weren't tiering toya but were doing overall you would probably still need to be playing during that time???? unless i'm really mistaken about how long this lasted, i imagine it has to be an absolutely tiny number of ppl whose runs were genuinely harmed by that mistake. the krsekai issue with the tamagotchi collab is like. unfortunate ig. thats all i have to say there. but the majority of ppl playing on the primarily english-speaking pjsktwt aren't playing krsekai (at least not as their main server) so idk why we're making a big deal out of that one.
wow that was a lot of words to just say "man i think we're all being really dramatic about a number of small errors across probably multiple teams that got blown out of proportion when the vast majority of players weren't harmed at all." however i also have one last point in line with this: why the fuck does everyone hate character pick vouchers??? do you have any clue??? i feel like everyone is hating on character pick vouchers but like. idk man i kind of like being able to pick up cards or get wish jewels every so often.
ALSO like...... i think the increased focus on character pick vouchers on EN is clearly because of the restrictions that some regions have placed on minors being able to pull with crystals at all + the ongoing like, legislative threat of similar restrictions in other regions (countries have been cracking down on other gambling and gambling-like mechanics in games for ages, i feel like i've heard so much about lootboxes over the past decade or so). i would also guess that the safest option is for colopale to put in a system that isn't "gambling" at all (ruling out most ticket approaches) so players can guarantee the card they want.
this system is so just new and afaik they haven't ruled out anything like adding more cards to the selection pool... i think we should all just be a little patient with them. if there hasnt been an expansion by like the one-year mark then maybe we can start getting bitchy about it LOL. they've been a lot better about the number of pick vouchers theyve provided lately too, so i feel like this system still has a lot of room to grow. and honestly even if it turns into the wish jewel factory i'm probably okay with that too tbh LOL. for some teenager stuck behind some silly restrictions against pulling with free crystals, i'm sure this system is like their best way of getting new cards (AND being able to guarantee a star rather than just pulling and getting duds repeatedly!)
OKAY i think my rant is over now. please share your opinions in response because i think you feel similarly about some of these things based on your posting but i would love to know if you have a nuance hat for these. o/ and o7 !!
wb sayanon!
i think this is a hot take but i do absolutely think the compensation is fine, at least generally speaking. like. i get it. it sucks that this happened and it should not have happened and i am holding colopal accountable, but also like...
Let's look at this realistically. The maintenance was already scheduled, so we knew about that, and it affects everybody equally. I still don't know WHY they scheduled a maintenance during DDFL, but there were likely extenuating circumstances, so I will forgive John Colopal for wanting to go home to be with his wife and kids or whatever the fuck. That's a non-issue.
The maintenance EXTENSION is unfortunate, but shit happens. It was only two hours extra on regular maintenance, and I'm still subscribing to the 'they spilled coffee on the computer' theory, so there was nothing they could do about that.
Then. Uh. Paid crystals disappear (and also some other minor glitches lmao). This is bad! This should not have happened. This is John Colopal's fault, and he should be appropriately repentant. Then emergency maintenance to fix it, and everything is back to normal about... like, 12 hours later, total? Including the original maintenance? I don't actually recall, but it was in that general ballpark.
Cool. So the first maintenance, and the extension, were unfortunate, but probably unavoidable. Then the emergency maintenance needed to happen, so like, obviously. So the only issue here is the few hours where paid crystals disappeared.
Now, my heart genuinely goes out to all the tierers affected by this. This must have been awful to see, because DDFL is already super short, and it's a kasa event that's really good, so it's competitive, and everything. The tierers were absolutely and terribly affected and they have every right to be upset.
... but this didn't actually affect anybody else. Like, yes, it was disconcerting to see, and a lot of people panicked, but a lot of the panicking was completely baseless, because for some reason people thought the crystals weren't going to be recoverable? More on that in a sec, but tierers first.
I hate to say it, but, like.... like 100 people were affected by this, realistically speaking. Obviously tierers are the beating heart of pjsk and it fucking sucks that 100 tierers were affected by this, but it's still a really small number of people, for a really short period of time. If I were Colopal, I would actually probably figure out a metric to distribute compensation to the tierers specifically (like, anybody with over 10-20k paid crystals at the time of maintenance in the top 1000, or something?) because they DO deserve more than everybody else got, but for everybody else, which is most of us.... we weren't affected. A number disappeared for a little while, we got scared, and then it came back.
Now, part of the reason why everybody was scared WAS because of the fear a lot of people had that the crystals would be gone forever, or at least for a longer period of time than a couple hours. Since this is pretty deep into this alterspring, I'll put on my hater goggles for a moment, though I do apologise if this refers to you - if you genuinely thought that, you're either stupid or aren't technologically literate enough to own a credit card. Yeah, man, surely they don't back things up before fucking maintenance. Obviously. They wouldn't back up THE THINGS PEOPLE PAY MONEY FOR or anything. Nope, all gone, all down the drain. They actually were going to just assume people wouldn't notice! Maybe they'll give out 3 small cans as compensation and then just sweep it under the rug. Yeah, definitely, that makes sense! That's totally a thing a company would do! For suresies!
... I was very frustrated watching people's responses as this was unfolding, as you can probably tell. There are some very... There are certainly people in their official Discord, I'll tell you that much. I should not be this much of a hater, because I do understand it was a stressful situation, and tech literacy is nowhere near as developed as I wish it was, but, like. Man. Really?
Okay, all of that aside, we've established that, functionally, 100 people were genuinely (im)materially affected, because they were actively tiering and lost out on either several hours of tiering time, money from having to repurchase crystals to tier for that period, or were potentially subject to being boated through literally no fault of their own. That sucks! That's bad! But that's ALL that happened.
I have more qualms with colopal for how long their response took rather than anything involved or the compensation they offered. I have no idea how emergency maintenance didn't happen literally within 30 minutes of the servers coming back up. I can only assume that there was either a miscommunication (so the engineers didn't realise how severe the issue was), a misunderstanding (they thought/hoped they could restore it without emergency maintenance), or some inability to hit the maintenance switch (maybe John Colopal had already left the building to see his wife and kids and the junior engineers didn't have the keys to open the case around the giant red Maintenance Now button). Whatever it is, it shouldn't have happened, and maintenance should have happened way earlier, or, y'know, the issue shouldn't have happened at all, or failing THAT, the players should have had much earlier communication. They clearly fucked something up really badly, and that needs to be addressed internally.
But that isn't player-facing, so I don't really give too much of a shit about it, as long as it doesn't happen again.
A lot of people have this weird understanding that Project Sekai keeps on fucking up this year and you're completely right in pointing out that these issues literally are not all done by the same dev teams?? We KNOW the dev teams are separate between servers, for hopefully obvious reasons, and if you look at it in that light... each Project Sekai Game has had like one or two issues all year. That's pretty normal? It happens. Some of the issues are certainly quite large in potential affect, but in reality, the actual impact of them has been MASSIVELY overblown by people and I don't know if it's ignorance or spite that makes them so loud about these issues.
my hottest take is that i literally don't think the bloomfes issue was a problem. man not to parrot kondo but if you were genuinely spending any significant amount of money for .007 rates you might have a gambling addiction. sorry i KNOW the hater goggles are still on but my first response when i saw the initial issue (before the official response, to be clear) was literally "oh that sucks. were people actually pulling for Those Cards Specifically?? that's gotta be like a double digit number of people who missed out". and like yes i know that that still sucks and it's not like i'm saying there SHOULDN'T have been compensation, it was an actual mistake that again should not have happened, but, like. again. Man. is it really That bad. am i stupid?? am i just a bootlicker and the boots too deep for me to notice it?? i don't THINK i am.
ANYWAY yeah, no, I just genuinely think that this is a handful of unrelated issues across different dev teams and treating them as the Global Colopal Entity is a complete misunderstanding of how the development structure at pjskindustries works. It sucks that mistakes are made, but it happens, and I'm not going to hold it too severely against them until a) the same thing happens repeatedly or b) substantial real effects are felt by more than a fraction of a percentage of the playerbase.
They should still compensate the tierers more, though. They should do that. I imagine they won't, because that kind of thing is really hard to do without running into various concerns, but I do think they should.
Now, on to character pick vouchers: I have been in favor of character pick vouchers since they were first implemented, and my stance has not changed. They are an incredibly new and experimental currency, so it's clear colopal doesn't know exactly how to value them, and how often they should be distributed, but they are a guaranteed 4* (or a guaranteed 3*, which isn't actually bad if you're just having really shit luck) from an admittedly limited pool (for now! it could expand!) that is accessible to all players. I think they overvalued the cost of a voucher early on in their free giveaways, but they have been ramping up the rates at which they give them out over time, and we're very quickly approaching rates I would call completely reasonable and maybe even in the area of generous. I know it's not a perfect system, but I do really genuinely appreciate the implementation of this kind of system, particularly for newer players. I want them to expand the character pick pool, but, again, we are in the early and experimental days of the system. At least we can guarantee a 4*, and it's not like the 4* is bad, because there's no real powercreep in this game and the thing still counts for full off-banner EB even if it's a chopped first year 4*.
ugh i can tell i'm still wearing the hater goggles a little bit. sorry to anybody reading this who isn't sayanon (hi yes sayanon thank you for having pretty much the same opinions as me you're the goat) who thinks I'm being mean or not appropriately valuing one aspect or another of these debacles. Please feel free to talk to me either in DMs or in one of my askboxes if you want to argue with me, I love talking, but, like. I just... don't know why we're all SO angry. We shouldn't be this angry.
Except at John Colopal. That guy sucks. I hope his wife and kids divorce him. He probably left the office immediately after maintenance ended because he was sick of being at work and was halfway home by the time the junior engineers called him and begged him to come back and hit the maintenance button. Yes i'm writing ensekai dev fanfiction. John Colopal is Kondo's LDR situationship. Goodbye thanks for reading yell at me if you think i'm stupid
Curious what you thought of ddfl! Interesting that you have such a positive reaction to it when i remember the fandom reaction was quite mixed back when it released in jp.
Wait, people didn't like it initially? Why not? Was it because it's a character-driven event with good writing that takes a significant turn from what WxS has been doing to really hone in on an aspect of acting and use it to both contrast and add to Tsukasa's character and wxs as a whole, and that's all full of nuance and intrigue and you need to actually read the text to appreciate it?
But okay let me actually discuss it instead of being really sassy and tongue in cheek.
DDFL is a fucking fantastic event. It does 3 things really well:
1. It does an incredible job with tsukasa.
2. It presents a genuine look at aspects of acting and depicts them with actual nuance and development
3. Despite being a focus event, ALL four characters get a lot of time to shine and really do all add a lot to the narrative.
I'll tackle 2 first, because it's the easiest - they feel like they're acting in this one! They feel like they're actually talking and working through their techniques and working together! My favorite scene in the event is actually the scene (and the area around it) where everybody works with Nene with blocking because Tsukasa is so big and loud that she needs to act around it. It's just a little scene but it's really really good! It feels natural! It feels like everybody is actually working together! Also it's really cute go my polysho or whatever. Obviously I love the final scenes too but That is genuinely my favorite scene in the chapter.
On to 3, which was covered a lot in the previous point but I've got more to say: despite being a Tsukasa focus, Nene is actually the protagonist of their play, and I think that she gets a lot of time to shine in this event! nenekasa stocks actually go up a lot in this event imo which is impressive since that's not a wxsquareship I'm super convinced on yet. Rui obviously writes the damn play, and just the fact that he wrote it is an impressive showcase of his abilities (and the start of the event is a great showcase of his gap moe, when he walks straight past wxs because he's too lost in his thoughts. dumbass. is he single) but more importantly he also does some really nice work during the acting portions especially with how he works with Tsukasa on. y'know. Scene Direction. and then emu is so nice!! and she has actual insight!! and she's so sweet and so proud of tsukasa!! and then asahi is really good too! and the slime man is here too and is appropriately slimy.
This is all to say that all the characters in the episode get a good amount of time and they all feel important in a way that's really endearing and highlights some of the best of what WxS can offer.
And, finally: Tsukasa. god fucking damn, Tsukasa Tenma, you might actually be a future star with this one.
So the crux of this event is the fact that Bless(e) is going through something that is totally alien to Tsukasa, right? So he has to actingslop his way into Understanding The Role. So we see that and we go Oh Yeah Sure another acting event. and then it ISN'T. this is an acting event, sure, but more than anything the character of Bless(e) is used as a character foil to Tsukasa to highlight Tsukasa's greatest strengths, which are aspects of his characterisation that have been previously developed, and expand on what it is that makes him Tick and then we find out what it is that can make him Break. That's so good! That's what the roles in wxs are designed for! That's what all of Tsukasa's actingslop is meant to achieve!
And then when they actually execute it and Perform everything in the episodes is super well done. The voice acting is SUPER on point, visual effects are done super well, character reactions to the scenes are used really well to highlight the point of the scenes without feeling overbearing. and then they go godtier and blast you with the Tsukasa card art and you can Feel the scene in your Bones and you go okay yeah i forgot you still had hands gacha game.
I could do a more like. Rational write-up maybe but honestly I'm not quite educated enough to fully analyse a lot of the techniques in a way I'd be satisfied with (maybe I should have done that English degree after all...) without like a day or so of writing, but the answer really is just This Event Was Really Good Cause They Wrote It Well. imo. lmao. it's so much harder to analyse things they do well than things they do poorly because I'm just good enough at writing to produce things that are better than bad but i don't actually know enough to meaningfully contribute to why good things are as good as they are. if i could pinpoint that shit my own writing would be better because I'd incorporate it more.
also like seriously i really like how they portrayed the acting in this event. i am not an actor and have never done beyond a modicum of toddler level theatre so i can't actually speak to its accuracy but it felt way less handwavey than a lot of events do. I am personally incredibly weak to scenes like this when done well (all you need to do in a vbs event is mention actual vocal techniques and my ears perk up) and this event was really convincing, at least to me.
Anyway thank you for your ask! I hope that satisfied your curiosity, feel free to ask for more elaboration or for me to address anything particular or to tell me I'm a loser or whatever you want if you feel so inclined. I still have no idea why the reaction to ddfl would have been mixed. If it's just the en side you're talking about I can make some guesses (nobody can fucking read) but, like, if it was jp side too? Wild stuff.
hii sayanon back!! cute nickname and also what i was thinking about suggesting myself originally HAHA. so that works out!!
wow!! it's been just a horrible week on pjsktwt!!! lots and lots of bad things happening, so it's understandable that i've seen a lot of ppl expressing a general fatigue with the game as a whole. but in addition to that, i've also seen a lot of people just saying that they're bored with the game/story/etc. and i have a theory on that that i would like to bounce off of you and a proposed solution:
i think a lot of the general dissatisfaction ppl have felt about everything in game/related media boils down to like. thinking about this game too much. i'm a fairly new player all things considered so i love to think about the game all the time, but that's because there's a huge backlog of things for me to work through — even having finished the global story a while back, i feel like i'm still learning new things about these characters and their world all the time. and of course there's a super rich assortment of headcanons and readings and fan theories to explore, even if i often find myself disagreeing with other people HAHA.
but with that in mind, i think for ppl who have engaged with this series a lot more... i don't really think you can sustain that level of engagement long term? to bring love live into this, i've been a love live fan for like twelve years now — and unless there's something big and new to work on, my engagement with the series is often limited to enjoying new music and seeing the highlights of lovelivedays every month. obviously, there are periods where i'm more engaged, but i often find that i can't find enough things to be SUPER excited about all the time, so i let myself engage more casually.
this tangent is all to say: i think that a not-insignificant number of pjsk fans are trying to engage WAYYYY too much with the story at all times and might need to readjust their expectations some. and when there isn't enough story for them to engage with, they start engaging with fan content instead, which produces the pressure cooker of Fandom Anger until everything inside is just toxic sludge. i think it's okay to acknowledge that when you've been into the game for a long time, you might be better served to actually revisit it every couple months to catch up on events, or something like that. or maybe you want to keep playing every day, but you don't have to obsess over getting every card for your oshi or tiering for events you just aren't that interested in, even if it's your oshi's event. having tiered several times lately, i knowwww that shit burns most people out!!
anyway i promised solutions so here goes:
we all have to stop obsessing over the machine-translated stories the second the jp leaks drop. it's not an intended way to experience the story in ANY manner — language, story unlock pacing, audio/visual elements, translation quality, etc. — and i think a large number of ppl experiencing a shittier, poorly translated version of the story is genuinely like ruining the vibes. plus when you've already read the machine-translated story in full and like obsessed over it i think it kind of makes your experience worse on global when the event actually hits with a proper translation. i've been into anime long enough to know that even minor translation inconsistencies tend to piss ppl off, even when the machine-translated or fan-translated version was itself the one that was wrong. FOR THE RECORD: i have read plenty of jp leaks and know roughly what happens in each story over the next year of global content, but i realized pretty early in trying to "catch up" to jp that i was like. not enjoying the really stripped-down, worse experience LOL
we all need to get a little more okay with the idea that gacha games are not meant to be 100%'d, no not even for your oshi. it's ok to think a card is ugly or an event is a flop and decide u don't want to tier for it or spend your real-life money on the cards or whatever. i love spending my real-life money on cards but i sometimes look at knmf cards and go "nah shes kind of not doing it for me" and skip LOL. you really truly do not need to force yourself to engage with it if you don't like it. ALSO: pjsk has such minimal powercreep that once you have five 4 stars of any character you have like, 95% of what you'll ever need. and even if you only have ONE 4 star for a character that's still like 80% of what you need. with some relatively small exceptions, any 4 star for a character is like... interchangeable with any other 4 star of that character, barring attribute. so like any cute mafuyu is interchangeable with any other cute mafuyu for like 95% of applications. and that's ok!!! it means i don't need every cute mafuyu, only A Pair Of Smiles Mafuyu sourced from N25 World Link 2, the most beautiful card in the game.
ALSO in line with that: it's totally ok to engage with the game by like. just logging in every day. just doing your dailies, whatever "dailies" means to you. stuff like that. yes, you might miss out on some resources or whatever, but theres literally no point in making yourself play if you aren't having fun. if you just want to play the rhythm game and not think about the story you can!!! you don't have to like Give Up on the game just because your relationship to it has changed, though obviously you can quit if you want to but like yknow
OKAY those are my big ones. basically we all need to think about this game a little less and become okay with the fact that as we play the game for longer we will necessarily become less interested in it and as a result we have to adjust our expectations for long-term enjoyment.
as one last note: pentatonic 2dmv.... it's silly but i kind of like it. i know ppl are like crashing out about it but i thought it was cute. i agree with the take that this was probably like their original concept for world link 2, what with the like... dark Doubt appearing in the sky and "destroying" the sekai and stuff like that. i think that actually would have been a lot cooler than Black Flecks on the leaves but i imagine that it would have required way too many custom assets when compared to what we actually got. i think it's cute and the production was clearly very troubled and also the yearly recap wouldn't have been super interesting for like, most units? so i'm happy with what we got.
that was a lot of text to just say "we all need to be more normal about this game" but so it goes........ i will return in the future with more yapping o7
pov you read the plaintext mtl script of a game with live2d and voice acting and music and you wonder why it's boring
anyway hello and welcome back sayanon! Yeah no it's been kind of miserable this past week lmao I don't know why everybody is so mad. Like I know why people are mad but I don't know why people are MAD like this.
I wish people could be more normal about their hyperfixations. I'm including myself here, because I often autism beam myself so hard into something that I literally just run either it or myself into the ground, but I at least have the functional capacity to separate my self-inflicted exhaustion from legitimate criticism of whatever I'm using as kindling.
This game is 6 years old, with new story content every single week. This is an insane pace to consistently consume, and most people just are not cut out for it, and will burn themselves out on it. This is not their fault, and it is not the game's fault. It is simply the way things are, because human beings have a capacity to how much they can repeat things.
Additionally, I feel like there's this weird constant demand that the fandom Needs to be Doing Things? Like whenever we're in a little bit of a lull I see people complaining "nobody's even talking about [x] anymore" or "does anybody even care pjsktwt is so dead lmao" (i am not thinking about anything in particular there i just know i have seen it before and am thus creating a strawman) and like. Fandoms do this all the time but oh my god can we not just have any time to sit with a story and digest it? We can't have any time to do Other Things? We have to have the subway surfers of pjsktwt on the side of our screen all the time??
alright this is my favorite thing you've brought up so I'm gonna just rant for a minute, and I apologise in advance for how much angrier this is than my usual Nuanced Opinions:
I fucking detest the way everybody responds to the jp story releases. Not only is everybody reading them minute 0 because we're all fucking chomping at the bit for any and all leaks, but we're immediately running them through google translate (at BEST because i know some ppl are definitely using grok-quality "every vocaloid is Miku Hatsune" AI translation) to read the misadventures of fucking apricot and one song as they stumble through text you have to try and puzzle out through context clues that loses literally all of the nuance of the original japanese or the localised English?? and then even if you do read a better translation or God forbid Understand Japanese you then have one or two people's early interpretations of somebody else's story that cement themselves in your brain as Explicitly Canon and then when the EN localisation comes out it has to Perfectly Match what you want or it is Literally Ruining Everything. I have my issues with the EN localisation - particularly recently, guys please lock in - but a lot of the way people react to it has absolutely no respect for the nuance and complexity associated with translation. also i think most of the translations of the jp version that aren't the en localisation are fucking boring and suck ass because they're translated 'more accurately' but aren't written well because nobody remembers that localisers also have to Write The Text in a way that is both Natural and Enjoyable To Read and just plainly translating Japanese basically exclusively results in really stymied and unnatural English that the internet has been mocking for literal decades. also we have absolutely no appreciation for spoilers or the concept of a global only reader in this fandom. ppl are discussing the end of an event the day after it releases and because we all work off the jp schedule everybody just Assumes everybody knows what happens in what is 6 months in the future for en players and like I get it but also oh my god getting into this game is so fucking annoying. no wonder so many people don't even read the stories in this fandom they're all reading shitty fan translations and getting bored. yeah no i imagine you all do hate MMJ when they're a unit carried entirely by the strength and charm of their characters, something that is much harder to write if all you're doing is translating instead of localising.
... where was I? What am I doing? Oh, right. Uh. Yeah I don't really like the way the en fandom does stuff with the jp release schedule and while I fully understand why it works this way and do not blame anyone who participates in it (because i do too, at least to some extent) it still makes me mad because I don't like it. I do not have a solution to this unless somebody wants to make like, the reverse tower of Babel, or we all agree to maybe chill on making opinions on events we only kind of understand the full nuances of.
ANYWAY all that aside, next point: there is literally no power creep in this game other than the Fes cards. Like obviously I also want to pull for the pretty pngs and get all the Ena cards and get her to cr1000, but like... You can still play the game without Every Card. It's not even like you need a perfect team to tier. people run 3*s in their top 100 teams all the time it just makes it a little harder. People act like the game is really unforgiving in the gacha, and it kiiiind of is, but you also don't need to pull? Like ever? So saving is way easier?
I don't know. This is one of my more controversial opinions and I know that, but I also come from the time before sparks and pity were even a thing in gacha games (i was a release fire emblem heroes player), and so the fact that I can spend 60k crystals and guarantee the card I want is still more than enough for me. Maybe I'm easily tricked. I don't know. But I just don't feel like I need to pull as often as everybody else seems to, and I don't feel anywhere near as poor as everybody else acts like they are?
I kind of already addressed this part but yeah no it is totally fine for ppl to just, like... play casually. That's okay. Take breaks! Relax! The game will still be there next month. They don't tax you for wasted nats.
and finally, pentatonic mv: This one is so funny because I just really don't care about mvs - that's just a personal thing I watch them once and go 'oh that was pretty' or 'eh whatever's and then move on - and so. I just do not care about this. I have no attachment to the concept of an anniversary mv and I am very amused watching people change their minds as they come back from the whiplash of "this isn't what I wanted" and go "okay but it's pretty good though hold on". We all need to stop being mad when something is different from what we expected
But also for the record I totally do understand why a year of anticipation for One Thing and it being completely randomly and out of nowhere Completely Different sucks. Like I know I'm poking fun but that is a completely normal kneejerk reaction and we all do it I don't blame anybody for that I just also know that we all need to stop giving our opinions the minute we form them and should instead wait a day or two to make up our minds. Actually yeah no that's my final take on this. As I've said before, we all need to be banned from talking about things until we've had a day to think about it. I thought the mv was cool even if it wasn't expected and it does feel like a scrapped wl2 concept
okay rambling done. it was 3am here when I wrote most of this so i know it's more incoherent than usual but what ever I'm sleepy. Thank you as always for your ask sayanon i hope you have a nice day!!
Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text* for italic text
**bold text** for bold text
[link](https://example.com) for link