Anonymous · 2mo

sayanon!!

hello i have to discoursepost a little bit. top of the post: i think we're all being a little bit unrealistic when we say pjsk is "targeted at" young teenagers. i wouldn't say that's necessarily the case; i think young teenagers are PART OF the general expected audience, and so the story is designed as such that it's GENERALLY appropriate for them. realistically, i feel as though the game is targeted at mid-late teens and adults under ~30, a group that sounds really broad but actually primarily includes "people with low oversight on their spending habits and significant disposable income" eg. teenagers working summer jobs or young professionals (you could narrow this range, generally, to 16–25). basically EVERY gacha game is targeted at this range by nature of being a gacha game.

honestly, i just don't buy the idea that the average 12-year-old is meaningfully engaging with this game and its story and characters, and i'm saying this as someone who was once myself 12 and playing SIF before school every day. i only liked love live because there were several ways to consume the story and characters beyond "5000 hours of kind of boring gacha game storyline that you have to catch up on to really understand what's happening" (good lord if it was just the SIF story i would NOT have liked love live). 12-year-olds, broadly, just kind of dgaf about anything that isn't like, as exciting and fun and novel as a giant laser pointer being waved around for them to chase, and reading years and years of story backlog is not going to do it for most kids. i personally know someone who is 13 and plays this game without reading anything and i think just thinks "akito is hot" while trying to build the "Most Aesthetic" team she can. that doesn't mean every kid does this, but i'm more inclined to believe that most do.

i also want to note that i think pretty significant portions of the pjsk story are genuinely very hard for young teenagers to properly understand the emotional resonance of. i think light up the fire is a big one here (honestly, the vivid street adults in general are part of this) but i also think a lot of the nightcord story is like, genuinely more mature than we're giving it credit for. yes we talk around words like "suicide" all the time, but it's fair to say that the game often interfaces with the ideas that adults have their own complex interiorities that they sometimes take out inappropriately on kids, especially THEIR kids. mafuyu's mother is a big part of this here, but so too is shinei, so too are taiga and nagi, and i think one could make such an argument for harumichi as well. a game truly "targeted at kids" (similarly to young adult literature) is one that would engage much more heavily with the idea of "my dad is just evil actually"; i think this is important just because the story has worked SO HARD to portray the idea that shinei is a complex man with his own complex problems AND ena knows that she was tough to handle when she was younger and her father wasn't entirely wrong AND ena is still mad about it because he was being a dick as a result and that wasn't fair to her. that's a lot for the "Target audience" of Young Teens to try to process mentally, and i think the depth of it really can only be understood by someone old enough to have proper hindsight on their childhood.

ok but like the actual discourse: this isn't to say anything about the concept of "sexualizing" characters in this game; i think it's ok (and we all need to get a little more comfortable with the idea overall) that you can be Kind Of Weird and there's nothing wrong with being Kind Of Weird sometimes. more on this in a second but tbh it requires a broader discussion on Characters and Fiction first.

more importantly, i think we all tend to forget that everyone's understanding of any character is actually like... their own personal abstraction of that character as exists in Their Head, Individually. my version of mafuyu is different from your version of mafuyu is different from someone else's mafuyu is different from the canon mafuyu. as a result, my version of mafuyu is influenced by all sorts of things about me — my age, my personality, my interests, my priorities in life. that doesn't mean i think mafuyu is a grad student who likes love live, but it does mean that my mafuyu is influenced by being part of the imagination of a grad student who likes love live. that means that my version of mafuyu is influenced both by the things i thought and felt around her age but also the things i think and feel now. my mafuyu is (to an extent) both 18 and my age, because she is influenced (even in ways i probably can't identify directly!) by the fact that I Am My Current Age.

i say all of this because i think we've kind of conflated all discussion of sexuality with these characters as being "weird." but i do think that's a little silly? people can certainly be weird about it, but i think we're all acting like sex and sexuality aren't important parts of "coming of age" (and, in most cases, the general concept of a coming of age story); pjsk is unusually allergic to discussing it because they don't want even a hint of an implication that two characters might be Dating-Dating (or similar things; i think this is a result of a mixed-gender cast, which most games like this don't really have). but like... i think it's okay to think about how these characters might wrestle with these experiences. i know i certainly was thinking about this a lot around the ages these characters are.

okayyy but all of that said: top/bottom discussion is one of those things that's like, unfortunately very timeless. i think it is just a rite of passage that every single like, teenager with an opinion has to progress from "top and bottom are a personality thing haha this character is such a bottom haha" to "ohhh actually this is just a sex thing and it's really weird to insist someone's sexual preferences are personality traits." i think younger ppl especially tend to think of it as another arbitrary Personality Classification in the same way as like "red/blue ship" and "pink/purple yuri" and stuff like that.... and it's a long-standing tradition that eventually you mature enough to go "ohhh uhh hm no it's no the same at all." i'm sure 14-year-olds were having this same debate about like, sasuke/naruto in the early 2000s, and i'm sure other 14-year-olds were doing it before that too, much in the same way that people are doing it today about pjsk characters and genshin characters and anything else trendy among young people. as you said: this has been discussed extensively, some of you are just 21.

that was a lot of words for my opinion to be "idk man maybe it depends" and "some of you are being very 21 about this" and "some of you are being even MORE 14 about this" and, ultimately, i must conclude with: i might be too old for this discourse, but by god that will NOT stop me from saying "you guys are all so fucking 12 about this please stop it." thanks for reading !!

hello sayanon! thank you for the feast

The question of what demographic pjsk is targeted at is complicated, because I think the answer really ultimately relies on one very silly little question: what do you mean by 'project sekai?'
I think there are three (and a half) separate axes pjsk operates on. One is the Vocaloid Rhythm Game, which is 1.5 axes, comprised mostly of the Vocaloid Rhythm Game but also partially just as a Vocaloid Game, one is the Tiering Gacha Game, where you spend a million dollars and play for 100 hours straight to get a funny png, and then the final one is the Visual Novel, where you read a 12 million page book and get emotional about anime girls. Not all of these aspects have perfect overlap in terms of what their core audience are, and I think that the game understands that, and a great part of its success is by allowing these axes to develop their own cores.
I completely agree that a lot of young teens - though I struggle to call a 13 year old a teenager, despite them literally being one - do not quite have the emotional maturity, in many cases, to fully grasp some of the complexities of the pjsk story. That's not to go "oh pjsk is actually the deepest storytelling ever" but rather that. Well. My little sister is 13, and is exactly as bad as the kid you describe. she literally will not read the stories. something something all the kids have adhd these days or whatever the stereotype is. i have no idea if i was that bad at 13 and just didn't know it or if exposure to tiktok is a type 12 carcinogen for the brain specifically but whatever it is I don't think most 13 year olds and younger I know are Capable of reading pjsk without copious application of the Ludovico Technique.
The visual novel of pjsk feels much more intended at probably the 15+ range, imo? but I also think it's worth acknowledging that it might just be that they've written a story that's actually good, and by introducing 'nuance' and 'developed characterisation' they've just written all-age-accessible media of a tier that we should be expecting more often. But again, as I said on twitter - the strength of a chain is its weakest link. To be frank, while we can while away about whether the game is intended for 10 or 13 or 15 or 36 year olds, the lowest age bracket the game intends to service IS low, and the game does make efforts to appeal and conform to the standards desired and required by those demographics, and there are always going to be children in these fandom spaces.

... this is a lot of words and I'm just kind of waffling in circles, so I'm just going to say my point properly to make sure it's coming out right:
Since the developers know and want young people to play the game, the game has to comport to certain standards. Despite this, the story does have a lot of wonderfully complex characterisation and narrative compared to contemporary 'children's media'. I am unsure why they write the story well, whether it's because they trust children to understand it or whether the story is primarily intended for the older portions of their player base. Regardless of this, the game is most definitely intended for minors, as in people who are under 18, and when we are engaging with the game, we should be mindful of that.

and all of THAT is to get around to the actual discourse:
You are completely correct that we all need to get a lot more understanding of the fact that the way we interpret fiction is ultimately something that mirrors aspects of ourselves. The moment you realise "who I am as a person interferes with every single part of my ability to internalise the world around me" is the moment you get a lot more capable of dealing with people who disagree with you on the internet. Either you see yourself in a character, or you can't, and both of these things inform how you interpret that character.

I... am glad we are this far down in the alterspring, so that I can say this with minimal chance of getting dogpiled by people taking this out of context: I think there is absolutely nothing wrong with discussing the sexuality and sexual behaviors (IN A NORMAL WAY) of fictional minors. I think some fiction SHOULD explore these things, and I think it is not only natural but completely healthy to want to explore these aspects of life in any kind of fiction you enjoy and partake in. Project Sekai itself does not choose to engage in these things, which is completely fine and not an issue at all (barring the occasional realisation of "damn surely one of them would have mentioned a crush by now") but. like. if you as a person want to discuss or think about or write about the concept of Ichika Hoshino Having Sex, Usually With A Woman But God Forbid Maybe Even With A Man, then that is, actually, completely fine. That being an aspect of the way you engage with this piece of fiction is a completely value-neutral concept. You are allowed to do that. In canon, even if you discard shipping entirely, if you view these characters as Real People, then a ton of them WOULD be wrestling with these things! Regardless of what you think Akito's sexuality is, the scenarios he is placed in for canon would almost certainly prompt some internal reflection on his part about his sexuality and how he feels about Various Sexual Things. that's NORMAL. we all went through this in puberty! or soon after puberty! even if your answer was "i'm not interested" you still had to figure that out!
Now, obviously, there are caveats to this. There are a ton of caveats to all of this. Most people who engage in sexual discussion of media publicly tend to be... a little strange... about it, and people who do not want to engage in it usually really do NOT want to engage with it, and even people who would engage in it otherwise will often feel personally uncomfortable with doing it to teenage characters, or doing it too Much with teenage characters, and often people who engage with it actively tend to play around with things that are bordering on or literally just actually both illegal and immoral, or whatever the fuck else, but there's so many things to evaluate there that trying to evaluate them all is a fool's errand. My stance on it will always, always, ALWAYS be that I cannot stop you from thinking and feeling whatever you think and feel, but if you know that it will hurt people or make them uncomfortable, you should at least make sure it is abundantly clear what they'll be getting into if they check your page. Like-
oh my god hold on i've just realised how long this tangent has been. good lord i get distracted when i don't have a character limit. anyway sex is a normal part of the human experience and wanting to explore it in fiction is a value-neutral concept and the important part is what you do after that and how you do it and how many people you hurt in the process (more than 0 is bad!). i am just a random person on the internet it is not my place to determine whether you've committed a thoughtcrime.

Anyway, top/bottom discourse: This is SO timeless. People have been doing this since fucking, kirk/spock, I'm pretty sure, and for some reason, it still hasn't stopped. Ultimately, top/bottom discourse is one of three things in my mind:
1) An actual discussion about how the two characters have sex. This is not something I personally care about, but if you care about it, good for you!
2) teenagers not understanding that this is literally a sex thing, as you've said (i have nothing meaningful to add lmao), or
3) the bizarre fucking 'who wears the pants' and 'okay but which one of you is the man and which one is the woman' hetero-ification of every single romantic and sexual dynamic that has ever existed ever. That's what most of it amounts to, in my experience, and if I think about it too hard I get really mad about it. So much of top/bottom discourse revolves around the dynamic of 'the bottom is the submissive one' and thus, by extension, 'the submissive one is the woman', and it's REALLY uncomfortable. I have hated the seme-uke Discussions literally since the day I found out about them, and my opinion has not wavered since that fateful day at like 14 years old or something. The fact of the matter is that most top/bottom discourse, when distilled to its base elements, is assigning the more Assertive or Dominant or Masculine one of the two to be the Top, the Man of the pair, and the more Feminine and Soft and Submissive of the two to be the Woman. And that's really gross! That's like super gross! But unfortunately it is not something we can avoid, because this kind of intrinsic understanding of a relationship dynamic is not baked into fandom culture as much as it's baked into the superstructure of capitalism itself, and none of us will be free of it for at least a few more generations. it still is definitely a sex thing though. like the fact that it's a more unconscious "who's the man and who's the woman" does not negate the fact that it's just a sexual dynamic thing. it's just that the Man v Woman dichotomy is ALSO a sex thing, because blah blah blah patriarchy etc etc if you're woke enough you know what i'm talking about and if you're not you tuned out like three paragraphs ago. anyway we need to stop treating sex dynamics as important aspects of shipping it's really weird and says a lot about the people talking about it.

I just went up to scan through what I've written and. Yeah, maybe I shouldn't have made an alterspring, actually, I sure know how to Yap. Ultimately, yeah, a lot of it is really complicated, and the answers to most of it are either "it depends", "it doesn't matter", or "you guys are being really weird about this for no reason". thank you for your ask and thank you for reading.

obligatory disclaimer at the bottom, because I don't trust Project Sekai Twitter as far as I can throw it: Hi! I'm a real human person. If you have an issue with something I've said, please DM me, or send me an ask, or something. I am sure I have glossed over something, or said something in a way you find weird, or whatever. I am always happy to discuss things with people. Please do not attack me because you thought the implications of something I said had bad vibes. No I do not endorse/encourage/enjoy anything that hurts or could hurt real life people, especially children. okay thank you for reading bye. 1886 words btw

Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting

*italic text* for italic text

**bold text** for bold text

[link](https://example.com) for link