Anonymous · 2mo

(sayanon!!)

was pleasantly surprised by how good the maintenance compensation was this time!! 700 crystals + 5 large cans is really pretty generous and was more than i expected even in the "holy shit maintenance 9/11" scenario. like tbh most ppl weren't harmed at all from this fuckup, but also it gave everyone quite the scare so i think this type of compensation was a really nice gesture from colopale. i think their biggest crime is that they probably should've approved someone tweeting/posting in the discord like "we are aware of a problem currently affecting paid crystals and are investigating the cause" like 30 minutes later instead of offering radio silence until the game went down again. i feel like a lot of the mass panic online arose just came from the lack of communication tbh.

that said, i feel awful for the kasa6 tierers LOL. short event made shorter by maintenance, then that maintenance got extended, THEN everyone's paid crystals were gone, AND THEN they had to go back into emergency maintenance. in my timezone, that was like the entire afternoon and evening so i didn't even get to do my dailies after work, and i just consider myself lucky that i'm not tiering this one. the paid crystals also uniquely fucked tierers over too, there were a couple hours in there where anyone in the upper LB had to choose between spending even MORE money and sacrificing tiering hours... i lowkey was wondering if they were going to extend the event after all of this, but no dice lol, i just won't be able to pick up the wish drops this time ig

i've seen a weird amount of doomposting from pjsktwt about this and im genuinely not sure why. in particular, i've seen a lot going on about "all of the problems" this year... and it's like, 6 short-lived kind-of-problems spread across four different teams? like the ppl responsible for the rui gacha nightmare are probably not the same people responsible for the en fuckup today. the rui gacha thing is like the only legit real "problem" all year, but i still feel like ppl blew it out of proportion a lot... it's literally pulling off-banner on bloomfes for very recent cards; realistically thats a very tiny number of ppl genuinely affected. in fact, the number was small enough that it took them several days to realize it happened in the first place LOL. it does suck for them, don't get me wrong, but it was like a legit mistake that only mattered to a small number of people, especially since the majority of players wouldn't have been pulling for those cards specifically and would have maybe picked up one or two of them incidentally.

i've also seen a lot of ppl talking about the VERY BRIEF window where ppl could get lims from ads on en, which is ALMOST CERTAINLY a different team entirely from the jp issues? idk i don't really know why people were mad about that one. you had your chance to get a lim from ads the same as anyone else, you just didn't roll it. to be clear: i did my ads that day and didn't roll the lim... bc i didn't roll a 4 star. getting a totally random lim from your ads with NO GUARANTEE that it will be useful or new to you or one you like at all....... idk man i just don't think that's a huge deal. it's kind of just the equivalent of doing a solo off recofes and going "oh shit a 4 star" and it turns out to be a lim. the biggest thing i would have done is left it running for the full 24 hours just to give all players an equal opportunity on it, but i also understand why they didn't. as for the most recent en issue i've already kind of said my piece on it, my main issue is that they did not post One Singular Tweet saying "we know about it uhhh we're working on it sorry" before the mass panic set in online.

anyway i'm obviously a global player but similarly i think the complaints about the tw/kr servers having that very short-lived issue with vbswl2 are like. also a bit overblown. i think they addressed it well. since it was a world link too like... if you were tiering for toya i think you would have probably been playing during that time anyway? such is the nature of tiering a wl chapter??? and if you weren't tiering toya but were doing overall you would probably still need to be playing during that time???? unless i'm really mistaken about how long this lasted, i imagine it has to be an absolutely tiny number of ppl whose runs were genuinely harmed by that mistake. the krsekai issue with the tamagotchi collab is like. unfortunate ig. thats all i have to say there. but the majority of ppl playing on the primarily english-speaking pjsktwt aren't playing krsekai (at least not as their main server) so idk why we're making a big deal out of that one.

wow that was a lot of words to just say "man i think we're all being really dramatic about a number of small errors across probably multiple teams that got blown out of proportion when the vast majority of players weren't harmed at all." however i also have one last point in line with this: why the fuck does everyone hate character pick vouchers??? do you have any clue??? i feel like everyone is hating on character pick vouchers but like. idk man i kind of like being able to pick up cards or get wish jewels every so often.

ALSO like...... i think the increased focus on character pick vouchers on EN is clearly because of the restrictions that some regions have placed on minors being able to pull with crystals at all + the ongoing like, legislative threat of similar restrictions in other regions (countries have been cracking down on other gambling and gambling-like mechanics in games for ages, i feel like i've heard so much about lootboxes over the past decade or so). i would also guess that the safest option is for colopale to put in a system that isn't "gambling" at all (ruling out most ticket approaches) so players can guarantee the card they want.

this system is so just new and afaik they haven't ruled out anything like adding more cards to the selection pool... i think we should all just be a little patient with them. if there hasnt been an expansion by like the one-year mark then maybe we can start getting bitchy about it LOL. they've been a lot better about the number of pick vouchers theyve provided lately too, so i feel like this system still has a lot of room to grow. and honestly even if it turns into the wish jewel factory i'm probably okay with that too tbh LOL. for some teenager stuck behind some silly restrictions against pulling with free crystals, i'm sure this system is like their best way of getting new cards (AND being able to guarantee a star rather than just pulling and getting duds repeatedly!)

OKAY i think my rant is over now. please share your opinions in response because i think you feel similarly about some of these things based on your posting but i would love to know if you have a nuance hat for these. o/ and o7 !!

wb sayanon!
i think this is a hot take but i do absolutely think the compensation is fine, at least generally speaking. like. i get it. it sucks that this happened and it should not have happened and i am holding colopal accountable, but also like...
Let's look at this realistically. The maintenance was already scheduled, so we knew about that, and it affects everybody equally. I still don't know WHY they scheduled a maintenance during DDFL, but there were likely extenuating circumstances, so I will forgive John Colopal for wanting to go home to be with his wife and kids or whatever the fuck. That's a non-issue.
The maintenance EXTENSION is unfortunate, but shit happens. It was only two hours extra on regular maintenance, and I'm still subscribing to the 'they spilled coffee on the computer' theory, so there was nothing they could do about that.
Then. Uh. Paid crystals disappear (and also some other minor glitches lmao). This is bad! This should not have happened. This is John Colopal's fault, and he should be appropriately repentant. Then emergency maintenance to fix it, and everything is back to normal about... like, 12 hours later, total? Including the original maintenance? I don't actually recall, but it was in that general ballpark.
Cool. So the first maintenance, and the extension, were unfortunate, but probably unavoidable. Then the emergency maintenance needed to happen, so like, obviously. So the only issue here is the few hours where paid crystals disappeared.
Now, my heart genuinely goes out to all the tierers affected by this. This must have been awful to see, because DDFL is already super short, and it's a kasa event that's really good, so it's competitive, and everything. The tierers were absolutely and terribly affected and they have every right to be upset.
... but this didn't actually affect anybody else. Like, yes, it was disconcerting to see, and a lot of people panicked, but a lot of the panicking was completely baseless, because for some reason people thought the crystals weren't going to be recoverable? More on that in a sec, but tierers first.
I hate to say it, but, like.... like 100 people were affected by this, realistically speaking. Obviously tierers are the beating heart of pjsk and it fucking sucks that 100 tierers were affected by this, but it's still a really small number of people, for a really short period of time. If I were Colopal, I would actually probably figure out a metric to distribute compensation to the tierers specifically (like, anybody with over 10-20k paid crystals at the time of maintenance in the top 1000, or something?) because they DO deserve more than everybody else got, but for everybody else, which is most of us.... we weren't affected. A number disappeared for a little while, we got scared, and then it came back.

Now, part of the reason why everybody was scared WAS because of the fear a lot of people had that the crystals would be gone forever, or at least for a longer period of time than a couple hours. Since this is pretty deep into this alterspring, I'll put on my hater goggles for a moment, though I do apologise if this refers to you - if you genuinely thought that, you're either stupid or aren't technologically literate enough to own a credit card. Yeah, man, surely they don't back things up before fucking maintenance. Obviously. They wouldn't back up THE THINGS PEOPLE PAY MONEY FOR or anything. Nope, all gone, all down the drain. They actually were going to just assume people wouldn't notice! Maybe they'll give out 3 small cans as compensation and then just sweep it under the rug. Yeah, definitely, that makes sense! That's totally a thing a company would do! For suresies!
... I was very frustrated watching people's responses as this was unfolding, as you can probably tell. There are some very... There are certainly people in their official Discord, I'll tell you that much. I should not be this much of a hater, because I do understand it was a stressful situation, and tech literacy is nowhere near as developed as I wish it was, but, like. Man. Really?

Okay, all of that aside, we've established that, functionally, 100 people were genuinely (im)materially affected, because they were actively tiering and lost out on either several hours of tiering time, money from having to repurchase crystals to tier for that period, or were potentially subject to being boated through literally no fault of their own. That sucks! That's bad! But that's ALL that happened.
I have more qualms with colopal for how long their response took rather than anything involved or the compensation they offered. I have no idea how emergency maintenance didn't happen literally within 30 minutes of the servers coming back up. I can only assume that there was either a miscommunication (so the engineers didn't realise how severe the issue was), a misunderstanding (they thought/hoped they could restore it without emergency maintenance), or some inability to hit the maintenance switch (maybe John Colopal had already left the building to see his wife and kids and the junior engineers didn't have the keys to open the case around the giant red Maintenance Now button). Whatever it is, it shouldn't have happened, and maintenance should have happened way earlier, or, y'know, the issue shouldn't have happened at all, or failing THAT, the players should have had much earlier communication. They clearly fucked something up really badly, and that needs to be addressed internally.
But that isn't player-facing, so I don't really give too much of a shit about it, as long as it doesn't happen again.
A lot of people have this weird understanding that Project Sekai keeps on fucking up this year and you're completely right in pointing out that these issues literally are not all done by the same dev teams?? We KNOW the dev teams are separate between servers, for hopefully obvious reasons, and if you look at it in that light... each Project Sekai Game has had like one or two issues all year. That's pretty normal? It happens. Some of the issues are certainly quite large in potential affect, but in reality, the actual impact of them has been MASSIVELY overblown by people and I don't know if it's ignorance or spite that makes them so loud about these issues.

my hottest take is that i literally don't think the bloomfes issue was a problem. man not to parrot kondo but if you were genuinely spending any significant amount of money for .007 rates you might have a gambling addiction. sorry i KNOW the hater goggles are still on but my first response when i saw the initial issue (before the official response, to be clear) was literally "oh that sucks. were people actually pulling for Those Cards Specifically?? that's gotta be like a double digit number of people who missed out". and like yes i know that that still sucks and it's not like i'm saying there SHOULDN'T have been compensation, it was an actual mistake that again should not have happened, but, like. again. Man. is it really That bad. am i stupid?? am i just a bootlicker and the boots too deep for me to notice it?? i don't THINK i am.

ANYWAY yeah, no, I just genuinely think that this is a handful of unrelated issues across different dev teams and treating them as the Global Colopal Entity is a complete misunderstanding of how the development structure at pjskindustries works. It sucks that mistakes are made, but it happens, and I'm not going to hold it too severely against them until a) the same thing happens repeatedly or b) substantial real effects are felt by more than a fraction of a percentage of the playerbase.
They should still compensate the tierers more, though. They should do that. I imagine they won't, because that kind of thing is really hard to do without running into various concerns, but I do think they should.

Now, on to character pick vouchers: I have been in favor of character pick vouchers since they were first implemented, and my stance has not changed. They are an incredibly new and experimental currency, so it's clear colopal doesn't know exactly how to value them, and how often they should be distributed, but they are a guaranteed 4* (or a guaranteed 3*, which isn't actually bad if you're just having really shit luck) from an admittedly limited pool (for now! it could expand!) that is accessible to all players. I think they overvalued the cost of a voucher early on in their free giveaways, but they have been ramping up the rates at which they give them out over time, and we're very quickly approaching rates I would call completely reasonable and maybe even in the area of generous. I know it's not a perfect system, but I do really genuinely appreciate the implementation of this kind of system, particularly for newer players. I want them to expand the character pick pool, but, again, we are in the early and experimental days of the system. At least we can guarantee a 4*, and it's not like the 4* is bad, because there's no real powercreep in this game and the thing still counts for full off-banner EB even if it's a chopped first year 4*.

ugh i can tell i'm still wearing the hater goggles a little bit. sorry to anybody reading this who isn't sayanon (hi yes sayanon thank you for having pretty much the same opinions as me you're the goat) who thinks I'm being mean or not appropriately valuing one aspect or another of these debacles. Please feel free to talk to me either in DMs or in one of my askboxes if you want to argue with me, I love talking, but, like. I just... don't know why we're all SO angry. We shouldn't be this angry.

Except at John Colopal. That guy sucks. I hope his wife and kids divorce him. He probably left the office immediately after maintenance ended because he was sick of being at work and was halfway home by the time the junior engineers called him and begged him to come back and hit the maintenance button. Yes i'm writing ensekai dev fanfiction. John Colopal is Kondo's LDR situationship. Goodbye thanks for reading yell at me if you think i'm stupid

Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting

*italic text* for italic text

**bold text** for bold text

[link](https://example.com) for link