(sayanon)
okay everyone time to pack it up we've done enough "is emu stingy by not paying for her friends to fly to the US" discourse and we're starting to move from jokes to being uncomfortably serious about this. so now i must write my impassioned defense of emu's spending habits because we are SLANDERING my girl and i refuse to let this stand unchallenged
emu is definitely the "rich girl" archetype in some ways, but i think it's important to remember that she explicitly defies them in other ways. yes, emu's family is genuinely comically rich and well-connected, but emu is NOT mari ohara, not even a little bit?? money is still very "real" to her, even if she spends extravagantly. more on this in a minute though.
first of all, i think the characterization of Capitalist Emu is just like. wrong lmfao. one of emu's primary motivations is protecting the financial viability of PXL, and we know she is actually embarrassed/frustrated by her own naivete on this front. her primary motivation for the past couple years of real time has focused on her learning how to make her dreams realistic without needing to compromise — she wants to improve her knowledge about management and finances so she can figure out how to make her aspirations for PXL work (rather than figuring out how to make PXL as profitable as possible). the whole point of emu6 is that she wants EVERYONE to be able to succeed, but she knows that their current structure can't support both troupes financially, so she sits down and tries to figure out a realistic solution to allow both troupes to continue.
importantly, i wanted to highlight her own embarrassment here — emu IS embarrassed that she used to be totally ignorant about the finances of the park. obviously, this is understandable (she is literally like 17), but she desperately wants to be taken seriously as a member of her own family (rather than just being the baby) and she KNOWS that that means she's going to have to get a lot smarter about business & start being more self-sufficient.
now, on the other hand, we DO know that emu spends extravagantly sometimes... but in the examples i've seen floating around (eg Rainbow Canvas) the whole point is that she's spending "her" money? yes she spent an insane amount of money on a tube of paint, but she notes it as being "her allowance" — this is money that is HERS, not money she's taking from the business. also obviously the reason the paint is so expensive is as a rich-girl-trope joke but this is a bit in a mixed event and i wouldn't take it too seriously regardless.
taken together, we know that emu is someone who comes from a lot of wealth and as a result has a pretty high standard of living derived from the people around her. she's definitely a person who like learned at age 10 or something that there's a part of the plane behind first class, thought that "flying normally" meant flying commercial instead of private, like, that type of situation. however, we also know that emu places a TON of importance on being financially responsible with the otori group's money, since she knows that every bit counts when it comes to keeping PXL (as she wants it to be) alive. we also know that emu is willing to leverage the non-financial resources she has (eg. connections, items the group already has) elsewhere to get opportunities her her and her friends.
i also think it's worth remember that wxs as a whole all feel deeply indebted to the otori group for what they HAVE received from them for "business purposes" (and also that the things they've received have been almost?? exclusively for business reasons). they've gotten to travel all around japan AND to the US before for business, because they WERE working, even if they spent a lot of time goofing around in the stories. obviously, as well, they've gotten a special deal to be pxl-affiliated freelancers, and the otori group's connections to other troupes are what let wxs get many of their present opportunities. i find it really unlikely that they would want to ask emu's family for even more??? truly???
as for "why did emu not offer to pay in nene7" — she almost certainly used her own money to buy her ticket, unless i'm mistaken (also it's not like the tenmas aren't ALSO quite rich, even if it isn't anywhere near otori-level...). do you think the average 17-year-old, especially one trying to be more responsible and business-minded, is going to ask her family business to finance a trip for her and some of her friends to go see a broadway show???? same applies for the "the otori group has a private jet" arguments. elephant in the room as well: it's just kind of boring if we use the otori group to justify everything wxs ever does lol
anyway tldr: nene7 is bad for its own reasons we need to stop slandering emu for being a dirty capitalist or whatever. my girl is just young and wants to be more responsible so she can have an actual say in how pxl runs. rant over thank u for reading
hiya saya!
This is a really good read thank you for this one! A lot of this covers things I've genuinely not thought about before this and I really appreciate your insight here!
I've been trying not to read into the jokes too much, because I was pretty sure they were just jokes, but I have felt kind of weird about the tone of a lot of them because they've been getting a lot more mean over time and I couldn't tell how much of it was me reading too into it vs it being actually mean-spirited.
I really do like the fact that emu being the Rich Girl archetype is explicitly relevant and massively impactful to her character arc and development. The Rich Girl who takes Private Helicopters to school or whatever is just an anime trope and it can be very funny so the use of it in pjsk wasn't unexpected but the way they kind of subverted it has been really nice to see! I feel like Wanting To Be A Manager is a character arc that people generally have a harder time connecting to - which I think is a worthy discussion in and of itself, that people don't treat emu's character that seriously because her arc is pretty distant from a lot of us - but I do really like it, especially with the overtones of misogyny implicit to her character.
As such, yeah, no, I completely agree with your takeaways. Emu's personal spending isn't actually on the company credit card, and that is important! Treating the Otori Group as her personal financiers would be really irresponsible and also make the Hyper Rich Conglomerate lose a lot of narrative weight (that they can't really afford to lose, lmao) and I'm glad they're not just leaning into the trope. Emu is more than a rich girl! She's a person too! She is aware of her privilege!
Thank you for ranting! My mental concept of Emu is still a little shaky compared to a lot of the other characters so this isn't the kind of thing I'd be super comfortable starting a discussion of, and so I really appreciate you bringing it up. I really like her, but she's just so easy to flanderise.
she deserves better. i love that little pink thing
Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text* for italic text
**bold text** for bold text
[link](https://example.com) for link