https://x.com/happynarrator/status/2109614307449487765
Hey, im the "not oomfs or anything" anon,
I understand that, but you cant keep talking about fem nb hcs as this part of bigger issue so easily, bcs as a fem nb myself, i want rep too. This isnt just a case where "we shldnt be fighting each other for rep", its also that we, as fem nbs, are fully allowed to see her as rep of us BCS she has ambiguity to her gender, even post-mizuena5, ESPECIALLY post-mizuena5, without being read as transmisogynistic. we are in the same boat, for the same character, and we love her, so so dearly.
So dont dismiss fem nb hcs of mizuki too easily with how u say it, thats all. Bcs its not fair to imply that us wanting rep as much as ANY QUEER does as this budding seed for tmisogyny. Its how ACTUAL misogynistic ppl choose to react to our want of this that wld cause more tmiso. Not us. Thats all..
/lh /nm
Srry i rlly am not super mad, and i do hope it dsnt come off that way, u just rlly irked me a bit haha.. i hope u understand ú_ù'" /gen
Look, girl, I don't know how to tell you this, and I really hope you understand I don't mean this with any hate or malice in my heart:
I can, and I will. There's a couple different avenues I want to explore this down, so please walk with me here.
Imagine, for a moment, that you see a person on the street. They are wearing a pink frilly dress, have their face done in full makeup, long hair, and have a high pitch to their voice. How do you refer to them, even in your head? Do you assume that she's a woman, or do you go "oh, I don't know them, so they could be anything?"
The 'woke' answer is "oh, I don't know them", but that isn't how you respond in reality. Nobody actually does. Everybody just makes assumptions, because we're human. You assume she's a woman, and treat her as such. You do this with every single woman you pass on the street. If you say otherwise, you are lying to me.
Okay, cool. Now, let's step forward a little. She's talking to her friends, and her voice slips. Suddenly, you recognise that she's clearly been doing voice training. Or maybe you get a little closer and you realise that she's a little tall, or that she has an Adam's apple, or that she looks a little more 'masculine' than you would have expected, or you notice they're wearing a trans pin, or you realise that you've heard about them before, and you know that they're trans (but it's just a rumour, so you don't know the full details). Maybe even you knew them when they were younger, and you know that they certainly didn't dress like that before. Whatever it is, you know that they're trans. You can tell they are not a cis woman. No other aspect of their presentation has changed, at least not intentionally.
How do you respond? Do you assume that she's a woman, or do you say that you don't know their pronouns, so it could be anything?
Do you see the issue here?
This is the entire crux of Mizuki's character. She wants to pass. She does not just want to be known as trans, she wants to be treated the same as any other girl. Every aspect of how she expresses herself is feminine, and she's horrified at the thought that people will interpret it any other way. By clocking the random trans woman on the street, you are actively dismantling every sign she is giving you that she is a trans WOMAN, and you are refusing to see her as she presents herself.
This is what I mean when I say this behavior perpetuates transmisogyny. Why do you think Mizuki is fem nb? Is it just because you, personally, are fem nb, and want to see yourself in the girl you love? Because that is completely fine! There is absolutely nothing wrong with that, and, congratulations, you have passed my woke test, collect your $0 and go on your way. But... What is Mizuki in canon? What do you think Mizuki is, in canon? Why is she canonically fem nb, instead of a binary trans woman? Because I don't care what you, personally, think as a headcanon. You are free to headcanon anything you want. But you don't exist in a vacuum, and I'm not really speaking to you, personally.
Additionally, I wholly reject that Mizuki has any ambiguity to her gender post mizuena5. We know explicitly that she is amab, that she becomes suicidal at the mere thought of that fact being exposed, and that she does not want to be seen as anything other than who she is. We know she does not want to be treated ANY DIFFERENTLY than she was before, which was, to Niigo, as a cis woman. There is no other way that they would have assumed she identified, because it doesn't make SENSE. In canon, they assumed she was a cis woman. The fact that the EN localisation started using they/them is literally a plot hole. We do not exist in a world where people use they/them as cis people. The only ways that Mizuki would have been referred to are as he/him or she/her, and we know damn well it wasn't he/him. So all Mizuki wants is for everything to go back to what it was before, where Niigo refers to her as a woman, and thinks of her as a woman, and in all way presumes that she is just a 'normal' woman.
What part of that reads as nonbinary?
Again, I don't mean any of this as a personal attack on you, the reader, specifically. But being queer doesn't prevent you from ever committing a micro- or macro-aggression, it doesn't prevent you from being transmisogynistic, and it doesn't mean you shouldn't engage in self-reflection.
Thanks for reading. I hope you understand my point. I do not mind if you disagree with me on some of the technicals, but please try to understand the totality of my argument, rather than quibble over any of the little details.
Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text* for italic text
**bold text** for bold text
[link](https://example.com) for link