wisteria vale · 4mo

Your whole research paper response feels unnecessarily long while missing the point. If you acknowledge that RPS exists in a grey area, then why create imaginary rules that only seem to make you feel comfortable? You admit you consume DDNE content, so you're part of the same community. You can't cherry-pick what you think is acceptable and then act as if you have the moral high ground.

If you're going to draw those lines, at least be consistent. Stop consuming DDNE and RPS altogether, because RPS itself exists in a grey area. We don't actually know these people's sexualities, and RPS has never been a space where those kinds of moral standards can be applied so cleanly.

I don't even know the anon who sent that message, but I can understand why they came to that conclusion. They aren't the only one who sees the contradiction. I do too, and I'm sure others have noticed it as well.

i think you’re conflating “being in a grey are” with “there being no distinctions inside that gray area.” those aren’t the same thing. saying rps/rpf sits in a grey area means judgment and context matter—it doesn’t mean every piece is equally fine to ANYONE just because the category as a whole is murky. you can hold this genre isn’t inherently wrong and this specific instance of it crossed a line at the same time, as a being who lives with agency.

the “you consume dd:dne (the right label btw), so you’re part of the same community,” so i can’t criticize? so i can’t leave my opinion? whether a critique holds up doesn’t depend on whether the person making it is personally spotless by some maximalist standard. if it did, nobody could ever critique anything inside a space they’re also a part of—no fan could ever call out bad behavior in fandom because they’d always technically be “part of the community.” that’s just silencing anyone with proximity to the issue.

the “we don’t even know these people’s sexuality” doesn’t actually respond to any of that because nobody was making claims about sexuality here. and i’ll say it plainly since it keeps getting skipped: the thing they asked to keep as the main focus—the minor and the bullying—still hasn’t been addressed here. only redirecting every time back to “you’re a hypocrite for having nsfw opinions at all,” maybe that’s you who actually want to avoid to address the topic of the main issue which i did explain it was my only main focus?

i am not claiming moral high ground or acting like i’ve never enjoyed anything messy. i didn’t deny either that people who still enjoyed ayes’ content are valid too. what i’m saying is that having agency means being able to notice where something stopped feeling okay for you, personally, and naming that—as a critique. multiple people reaching the same discomfort independently isn’t nothing. that’s worth sitting with, not dismissing as ‘imaginary rules’.

i can’t fully comprehend what are you talking about exactly because i never feel to ever moral-policing the issue because i only focused on calling them out as a pedophile (why can’t i hate a pedophile btw)..? if you witness some, go on them..? not me..?

Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting

*italic text* for italic text

**bold text** for bold text

[link](https://example.com) for link