Idgaf if Toby's technically not a creepypasta anymore HE IS MY FAVORITE
HE IS ONE IN MY HEART

You’re not going to believe with stories I like. Okay, cutting the bullshit, I’m a huge fan of Ticci Toby, Nina, and Liu’s stories. Yes, they’re simple and kind of guessable, but I still really like them. Especially Toby… I don’t care if he’s technically not a Creepypasta anymore. HE IS IN MY HEART.

oh there's so many... maybe Ticci Toby or Eyeless Jack

Ticci Toby, bloody painter, and homicidal Liu probably

not entirely associated with classic creepypastas, more just nosleep... but left/right game and tales from the gas station!

I was never too into creepypasta so i dont think i have a FAVVIE but i remember smile dog scared the shir outta me

Oooo I'm not rlly a creepypasta fan but my bsf is and it yapped to me abt laughing jack (idk if that's his name or not but that's what I remember) and ticci toby and I quite like those ones a bunch

I absolutely ADORE Candle Cove! I think Penpal is quite interesting as well.