Midnighter · 22d

Is it possible for a party to work long-term if some players pick, say, Lawful Good, while others pick Chaotic Evil?

First of all, alignments are bullshit. They're basically the tabletop equivalent of a horoscope. Some vague-ish details that might mean something to certain people about someone's general outlook and behavior, and can be kinda fun to play around with; but ultimately basically player or player-character is easily distilled down in such a manner that an alignment label will be completely apt.

This being said, you can make this work with the right circumstances. It takes a table of people willing to engage in some intra-party conflict, but also be flexible enough both in an out of character to keep the eye on the prize rather than 'everything wrong with them.'

Tales of Berseria is an excellent example of how to keep a party like this on track. It's lead character is basically C/E, a good chunk of the group are N/E, L/E or C/N. Then one character is L/G. There are clashes, there a disagreements, but ultimately they all get on the same page of "This effing guy needs to die yesterday". Of note; all of them are at their core, people. They have their own interests, hobbies and philosophies in addition to their goals and outlooks. They're also all messy disasters in one manner or another and just trying to carry on. Great game, big recommend.

Strong world-building and contexts beyond just the party themselves will facilitate a goal that is greater than the sum of it's parts, as well as the understanding that they are all stronger as a collective than an individual.

Alterspring uses Markdown for formatting

*italic text* for italic text

**bold text** for bold text

[link](https://example.com) for link